
Oh my God, I can’t believe you did this to yourself
again, Jillian. Every year, it’s the same thing. You say you’re not going to get involved with this tripe. You say you’ve got a million better things to do with your Tuesday and Wednesday nights, like putting your DVDs in alphabetical order and washing your hair... again. But then you catch some of those dreadful auditions and a couple of really awesome ones too– remember Paris doing “Take Five”? mind blowing!– and then you’re rooting for someone, and then you’re hooked! Again!
But really, is this show really complete tripe? I mean, sure, it’s schmaltzy and emotionally manipulative and sometimes cruel, but it’s also fun! And musical! And funny, particularly when Paula’s in a particularly deep in her drug-induced loopiness. And sometimes, it’s even sweet. (See: Elliott Yamin’s entire storyline this season.) It keeps me in step with the taste of millions of my fellow Americans. And it imbues communities with civic pride. Let’s face it. For better or worse, Raleigh has never rallied together like it did (and does) around Clay Aiken.
There! I feel much better about my continual enjoyment of this little show. Now, for the finale. Kat versus Taylor. Shrieky beauty pageant queen versus John Belushi doing Joe Cocker. I’ve liked Taylor (or “Gray,” as I unimaginatively call him) from early on, because dude, Joe Cocker is awesome. I’m not obscenely smitten with him as I have been with some contestants past (George! Bo!) But I do think he has a unique voice and great showmanship. And I haaaaaaate Kat. Hate. Not quite Diana DeGarmo/Scott Savol levels of hate, but very, very close. And Gray totally proved himself better than Kat last night. So he’d better pull through.
Now onto the show. These little duets with contestants and quasi-famous people always amuse me. Some of them are pretty cool - Vonzell with Billy Preston was awesome, even if no one but me knew who he was, and how happy did Bo Bice look when he got to sing with Skynyrd? However the duets so far tonight are just bizarre. They clearly hired Meatloaf just so someone in the room could look more doped up than Paula. And I really dislike Mary J. Blige. As Randy would say, dude, she’s pitchy. And she’s ignoring my beloved Elliott, who is a much better singer than she is. Boo showboating divas!
I hate these little music montages they make all the old contestants sing with the really bright themes like “songs with woman in the title.” They always manage to pick the absolute cheesiest songs ever. “Man, I Feel Like A Woman”? Wow, it took some poor AI intern about 2.2 seconds to suggest that one. Blah.
What the JEEBUS is going on with Raleigh’s Own Clay Aiken’s hair?!
I think, from a certain angle, Taylor Hicks looks a smidgen like Cary Grant. And now I really know I’ve been watching this show for too long. The next 8 months will be good for me.
Hang on a sec. The crappy guest singers are ending! It’s Burt Bacharach... and Dionne Warwick! LOVE her! And oh my God, they’re going to do “That’s What Friends Are For”! That song will always remind me of 5th grade girl scout camp. We were out in the woods in a tent during one of those awful North Carolina summer storms, and to keep ourselves unafraid and entertained, we sang “That’s What Friends Are For” and ate Hershey bars that were supposed to be saved to make s'mores. That’s one of the best awful songs ever! I would expect nothing less from my
Idol.
Prince!! Holy crap! You are WAY too cool for this show. Ummm.. Ok. And he’s not even dueting with Taylor and Katherine? Whatever, Your Purpleness.
Getting near results time at last. It’s sort of nice not to feel too emotionally involved with these contestants. Last year I was freaking out, praying for my Bo to pull it out. Man, I loved me some Bo. Although I must admit, Carrie has a lovely voice. She could outsing Kat McPhee any day of the freaking week.
Well, of course they’re singing “Time of my Life.” The crack AI intern staff has been hard at work again, picking out the Most Obvious Duet in History to have our finalists sing. It was “Up Where We Belong” last year (too bad, since Taylor's so Cocker-esque). Next year I’m calling Peter Cetera and Cher’s timeless joining of forces, “After All.” Then it’s “Muskrat Love” and then the world will implode.
Results time... agony and ecstasy... I notice they’re not even saying how close the votes were. Like remember when it was Clay and Ruben and they kept saying the difference was about one-one-millionth of an iota of a percent? There's none of that this year. So Taylor’s won by about 54 billion. Aaaaaaand...
I’m right. Gray wins. Hasselhoff cries. And I feel... strangely uninvolved. Maybe next year, I really won’t watch.
Right.